Advice

An Analysis Of Group 1 Races

Guest article written by David Renham from www.racingtrends.co.uk and www.punterprofits.co.uk

The other day I was calculating how many hours a week I put into horse racing. For most people a 40 hour week is pretty standard, but unlike the majority of people I work 7 days a week not 5. That tends to mount up extra hours pretty quickly especially as Saturdays I tend to work for 9 or 10 hours. Add another 3 or 4 on a Sunday and suddenly my weekly total of working hours starts to hit the 60 hour per week mark. Not that I am complaining, because I thoroughly enjoy what I do.

Most of my time is spent researching, running and contributing to two racing websites www.racingtrends.co.uk and www.punterprofits.com. However, one of the other things I do is write a weekly article for the Racing & Football Outlook newspaper. These articles normally focus on big races and their trends, both positive and negative. For example, I might look at the Derby at Epsom and the key trends over the past 20 years. It might be that the race may have proved profitable to follow favourites, or for horses that have won at Group level last time out, etc, etc.

For this article I have decided to work along similar lines but am going to look at the key trends/stats in Group 1 races over the past 10 seasons.

Group 1 races are the crème de la crème, with the best horses taking on each other at the very highest level. Over the past 10 full seasons (2000-2009) there have been 299 Group 1 contests in the UK and if you had used a pin to select a horse in each race, you would have lost around 32% of your money. Clearly this is not the way forward! Let us see how we can improve upon this.


Market trends

Favourites have had a very good record in Group 1 races over the past 10 seasons – backing all favourites (inc. joint favourites) would have produced 115 winners from 310 runners (SR 37.1%) for a profit of £1.74 (ROI +0.6%). Considering backing favourites in all races loses around 6.5% of your money, we can see that favourites in Group 1 races have been fairly good value. Indeed, I estimate that using Betfair or early prices that 0.6% return could have been improved to around 8-10%. OK, not a king’s ransom, but a fair profit nonetheless. The market generally has been a good guide with 70.5% of the races going to horses from the top three of the betting. For the record, the percentage figure for the top three in the betting in all races is 65%.

Genuine outsiders have little or no chance in Group 1 races. Horses priced 40/1 or bigger have produced just 2 winners from 636 runners (SR 0.3%) for losses of £544.00 (ROI -85.5%).

Finally in this section let us look at some more market facts and figs:

  • horses priced Evens or shorter have won 36 races from 57 races (SR 63.2%) for a small profit of £2.68 (ROI +4.7%);

  • horses priced between 11/4 and 11/2 have provided 101 winners from 476 runners (SR 21.2%) for a profit of £22.15 (ROI +4.7%);

  • favourites in 3yo only Group 1 races have produced 31 wins from 78 (SR 39.7%) for a healthy profit of £23.25 (ROI + 29.8%);

  • the top 3 in the betting have provided 78% of the winners of 2yo Group 1 races.


Trainer trends

In general, the more established trainers, with the backing of wealthy owners do best in Group 1 races. Let us look at the breakdown for trainers who have saddled at least 25 runners in the past 10 seasons. They are ordered by strike rate:

Trainer

Wins

Runners

SR%

Profit/loss

ROI %

John M Oxx

9

28

32.1

+£14.45

+51.6

J S Bolger

9

38

23.7

+£8.95

+23.6

E A L Dunlop

5

27

18.5

-£0.75

-2.8

A Fabre

5

31

16.1

-£14.56

-47.0

M L W Bell

5

32

15.6

+£7.75

+24.2

A P O’Brien

61

431

14.2

-£141.09

-32.7

T D Easterby

4

29

13.8

+£9.00

+31.0

M Johnston

8

60

13.3

+£0.25

+0.4

J H M Gosden

15

114

13.2

-£7.74

-6.8

Sir Michael Stoute

29

229

12.7

-£58.82

-25.7

L M Cumani

5

40

12.5

-£18.70

-46.8

J Noseda

8

66

12.1

-£20.25

-30.7

M A Jarvis

6

56

10.7

-£16.00

-28.6

Saeed Bin Suroor

26

248

10.5

-£70.75

-28.5

J R Fanshawe

5

52

9.6

-£24.40

-46.9

M P Tregoning

5

52

9.6

-£27.00

-51.9

P W Chapple-Hyam

4

42

9.5

-£9.05

-21.6

H R A Cecil

4

46

8.7

-£13.75

-29.9

D Nicholls

3

35

8.6

+£10.00

+28.6

C E Brittain

6

72

8.3

+£9.25

+12.9

R Charlton

2

25

8.0

-£11.00

-44.0

B W Hills

10

128

7.8

-£30.00

-23.4

B J Meehan

5

71

7.0

+£20.25

+28.5

K A Ryan

2

33

6.1

-£7.00

-21.2

R Hannon

4

98

4.1

-£59.67

-60.9

M R Channon

4

110

3.6

-£79.35

-72.1

J L Dunlop

2

70

2.9

-£40.25

-57.5

D R C Elsworth

0

73

0.0

-£73.00

-100.0

G A Butler

0

25

0.0

-£25.00

-100.0

W J Haggas

0

25

0.0

-£25.00

-100.0

Mrs A J Perrett

0

23

0.0

-£23.00

-100.0

It is very interesting to note the success of trainers from Ireland, with 3 of the first 6 places in the table taken by Irish trainers. In addition, French trainer Andre Fabre is 4th on the list. Clearly Irish and French runners demand close scrutiny. The overall figures for most trainers are poor though and you need to dig deeper to find profitable trends/stats. Here are some I have unearthed:

  • Aidan O’Brien has a very good record when saddling the favourite thanks to 38 winners from 74 (SR 51.4%) for a profit of £13.83 (ROI +18.7%);

  • John Oxx has saddled just 5 favourites but 4 have won;

  • Mark Johnston has done well with runners when they have been in the top three of the betting. He has secured 6 wins from 19 (SR 31.6%) for a profit of £13.25 (ROI +69.7%);

  • John Oxx has a great record with male runners. All 9 wins have come from male runners for a profit of £25.45 (ROI +149.7%).

Of course positive stats are useful, but negative stats have their place as well. Knowing which horses are very unlikely to win / have poor stats helps you to avoid those dreaded losers. Here are some trainer negatives to note:

  • John Dunlop has saddled 32 female runners producing 0 winners and just 3 placed horses;

  • Aidan O’Brien has a poor record with horses priced 10/1 or bigger. Just 4 wins from 219 runners for a loss of £147.00 (ROI -67.1%);

  • Mick Channon and Richard Hannon also have a poor record with horses priced 10/1 or bigger. 1 win from 93 and 1 win from 80 respectively illustrate this;

  • Sir Michael Stoute has a poor record with older runners aged 5 or more. Just 3 wins from 53 (SR 5.7%) for a loss of £34.00 (ROI -64.2%);

  • Saeed Bin Suroor’s runners struggle when off the track for a long time. Horses from his stable who have been off the track for more than 100 days have produced just 7 winners from 77 (SR 9.1%) for a loss of £50.55 (ROI -65.7%).


Age trends in Group 1 races

Around 40% of Group 1 races are races open to horses aged 3 or older (3yo+). Let us look at the age trends/stats for 3yo+ Group 1 races:

Age

Wins

Runners

SR%

Profit/loss

ROI %

3

54

447

12.1

-£27.81

-6.2

4

39

404

9.7

-£118.18

-29.3

5

22

222

9.9

-£23.75

-10.7

6

6

100

6.0

-£25.50

-25.5

7 or older

1

71

2.2

-£64.00

-90.1

As you can see, 3yos have a decent record – the best strike rate and losses of just over 6%. Horses aged 7 or older have a very poor record.

It should be noted that these older horses (7yo+) struggle in 4yo+ Group 1 races also with 2 wins from 50 (SR 4.0%) for a loss of £45.13 (ROI -90.3%). Indeed both wins in the 4yo+ races were won by the evergreen Yeats, so take him out of the equation and the remaining 48 runners were all beaten.


Position LTO trends

Let us look now at recent form by focusing on each horses’ most recent race.

Position LTO

Wins

Runners

SR%

Profit/loss

ROI %

1st

148

1127

13.1

-£322.06

-28.6

2nd

65

563

11.5

-£19.09

-3.4

3rd

31

374

8.3

-£127.41

-34.1

4th or worse

55

1187

4.6

-£580.88

-48.9

Horses that finished in the first three LTO have provided just under 82% of all Group 1 winners. The value seems to be with horses that finished 2nd LTO, while horses that finished 4th or worse LTO look best avoiding. It is also worth noting that 260 of the 299 winners (87%) had won at least once in their last three runs.


Jockey trends

In general, jockey data correlates with trainer data as stable jockeys tend to ride for their stables in the big Group 1 races. However, the better jockeys also tend to pick up some decent spare rides so it worth checking out the data. Let us look at the breakdown for jockeys who have ridden at least 25 runners in the past 10 seasons. They are ordered by strike rate:

Jockey

Wins

Runners

SR%

Profit/loss

ROI %

K J Manning

9

38

23.7

+£8.95

+23.6

J P Murtagh

39

167

23.4

+£42.61

+25.5

K Fallon

31

147

21.1

+£27.55

+18.7

L Dettori

31

205

15.1

-£23.78

-11.6

O Peslier

8

55

14.6

+£28.50

+51.8

P Robinson

8

66

12.1

-£16.50

-25.0

C Soumillon

4

41

9.8

-£30.61

-74.7

N Callan

4

41

9.8

+£4.00

+9.8

D Holland

9

95

9.5

+£4.75

+5.0

J F Egan

3

35

8.6

+£33.00

+94.3

J Fortune

11

129

8.5

-£68.18

-52.9

R Hills

11

131

8.4

-£17.25

-13.2

K McEvoy

5

63

7.9

+£6.00

+9.5

J P Spencer

11

154

7.1

-£66.95

-43.5

M Hills

6

95

6.3

-£40.50

-42.6

R Hughes

7

126

5.6

-£87.73

-69.6

Martin Dwyer

3

55

5.5

-£31.50

-57.3

R L Moore

5

101

5.0

-£41.38

-41.0

S Drowne

2

43

4.7

-£35.60

-82.8

T E Durcan

4

87

4.6

-£34.50

-39.7

S Sanders

3

68

4.4

+£17.00

+25.0

J A Heffernan

1

29

3.5

-£20.00

-69.0

P J Smullen

1

33

3.0

-£27.50

-83.3

W Supple

1

35

2.9

-£22.00

-62.9

T Quinn

2

81

2.5

-£74.00

-91.4

Pat Eddery

1

70

1.4

-£49.00

-70.0

E Ahern

0

43

0.0

-£43.00

-100.0

Dane O’Neill

0

29

0.0

-£29.00

-100.0

C O’Donoghue

0

28

0.0

-£28.00

-100.0

P J Scallan

0

28

0.0

-£28.00

-100.0

Manning who tops the tree has ridden all the time for Kevin Manning, whereas Johnny Murtagh has ridden winners for 9 different trainers, although 23 of the 39 have been for his boss O’Brien.

The advantage of backing horses in Group 1 races is that we know that all horses are trying their best. Hence we can be fairly confident in the trends/stats generated in this article. Let me finish by giving you a shortcut with a list of positives and negatives:

Positives


Favourites

Top 3 in the betting

3yos in 3yo+ races

At least one win in last 3 starts

Finished 2nd LTO

Irish trainers

Jockey – J Murtagh

Negatives


Finished 4th or worse LTO

Aged 7 or older

Outsiders priced 40/1+




Dave Renham is a leading uk horse racing researcher. He has worked in the past for the RacingPost and the Racing and Football Outlook newspaper. His own websites at www.racingtrends.co.uk and www.punterprofits.co.uk are great spots for finding out about profitable angles for your UK horse racing betting.

Michael Wilding

Michael started the Race Advisor in 2009 to help bettors become long-term profitable. After writing hundreds of articles I started to build software that contained my personal ratings. The Race Advisor has more factors for UK horse racing than any other site, and we pride ourselves on creating tools and strategies that are unique, and allow you to make a long-term profit without the need for tipsters. You can also check out my personal blog or my personal Instagram account.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
Close